Lifestyle Desires
A clapperboard held against a dark film-set background
Culture

What YouTube’s Gen Z directors are doing to Hollywood now

YouTube directors behind Backrooms and Obsession are turning internet horror into Hollywood’s new taste test, and the old gatekeeping story looks shakier.

Jordan Atkinson9 min read

Before the late session starts, a suburban multiplex has its own damp little perfume: warm popcorn, carpet cleaner, someone’s vanilla body spray drifting down the row. Nobody smells revolution in that room. Mostly you smell the screen saver ad for frozen Coke looping for the fifteenth time while a teenager three seats over tries to photograph the ceiling lights without looking as though they are photographing the ceiling lights.

Somehow, this is where the strange thing has landed. Not in a studio boardroom. Not in a film-school prospectus. In the ordinary dark, where two horror films made by directors who learnt their timing online have made old Hollywood look a bit late to its own party.

According to Guardian reporting, Backrooms opened to $81.4 million in the US and $118 million worldwide, with Kane Parsons becoming the 20-year-old director Hollywood now has to take seriously. Curry Barker’s Obsession has been carrying its own weight too, with New York Times reporting putting its North American haul at $74 million. Those numbers are the news hook. Fine. They are not the bit that keeps snagging in my head.

More tellingly, the multiplex is starting to sound like the internet did before brands discovered the word community and ruined it. Uneasy corridors. Bad lighting. A joke that curdles into dread. A camera that seems less interested in discovering the monster than admitting it has been there the whole time.

“It’s the start of a gigantic shift. These are the cinematic insurgents of our era.”
Stephen Galloway, quoted by The New York Times

Galloway’s line is a big swing. I am wary of calling anything an era while the popcorn is still warm. But I can see why it stuck. The Guardian framed the present wave as online Gen Z directors storming Hollywood, and for once the verb does not feel wildly overcooked. These directors are arriving with audiences already trained to recognise their grammar.

The corridor was already crowded

As origin stories go, Backrooms is gloriously untidy. No tasteful pitch deck. No mood board and lunch at Chateau Marmont. Its root system is messier: a 2019 4chan image, a creepypasta instinct, a YouTube series by Parsons under the name Kane Pixels, and the collective internet habit of turning a beige office corridor into a spiritual weather event. The Conversation AU has a useful account of how the Backrooms legend moved from anonymous post to A24 feature, a sentence that would have sounded like parody a decade ago.

Rows of empty cinema seats waiting for a late horror screening

Age alone does not explain the jolt. Hollywood has always enjoyed a prodigy when the prodigy can be made legible. The evidence trail feels newer. We do not have to imagine the apprenticeship because chunks of it are still sitting there online, viewable, pauseable, argued over in comments, remixed by people with usernames that sound like passwords. The New York Times cited 342 million views for Parsons’ videos. That is not a portfolio in the old sense. It is a public rehearsal with hecklers.

Yes, that sounds democratic, up to a point. I do not want to romanticise it too much. A teenager with time, software, a machine that can render, a house quiet enough to work in, and the temperament to survive the algorithm is still a very particular teenager. The gates have shifted. They have not dissolved. Even so, the old line that a director comes from the correct school, the correct assistant track, the correct short-film festival now feels less like a rule and more like a costume drama.

Parsons has been plain about the pace. In Wired’s interview, he put it with the bluntness of someone who has gone from bedroom-scale myth-making to studio attention before most people have worked out their rent.

“It’s been go, go, go.”
Kane Parsons, Wired

Tiny line, useful line. No grand manifesto. Just velocity.

The apprenticeship happened in public

“YouTube director” still carries a faint little sneer, as though the person holding the camera has wandered in from a prank channel wearing the wrong lanyard. That feels old now. YouTube has become a brutal, public workshop: write, shoot, post, watch the audience drift away at minute two, try again.

A cinema projector throws light through a dark projection room

Naturally, that workshop rewards some ugly habits. It can teach desperation. It can flatten taste into whatever survives a thumbnail. Parsons himself told The Verge that “the YouTube algorithm is not your friend”, which is the sort of sentence that should probably be printed on a mug and handed to every promising 19-year-old with a camera.

“The YouTube algorithm is not your friend.”
Kane Parsons, The Verge

Still, the workshop teaches timing in a way a closed classroom cannot. Attention starts to leak and you see it happen. A silence either holds or it does not. After a while, you learn that a fluorescent hum can be scarier than an orchestral sting if the frame has already taught the viewer to mistrust the room.

Perhaps that is the part Hollywood is buying without quite admitting it. Subscribers help, sure. A built-in audience helps more. But the real asset is fluency in a taste culture that formed outside studio marketing departments. The New Yorker’s review of Obsession and Backrooms reads the pair as part of a Zoomer horror moment, and even if one rolls their eyes at the label, the observation has weight. These films understand a generation raised on liminal spaces, ARG breadcrumbs, Discord theories and videos that feel as though they were recovered rather than released.

Amateur keeps coming back to me, not as an insult but as an origin story. Amateur comes with rough edges. It also comes with private obsessions the professional system tends to sand down. A studio can buy polish. It cannot always buy the weird little fixation that makes a viewer text three friends at midnight saying, you need to see this.

Horror knows how to use cheap light

Horror, conveniently, knows what to do with a bad room. A corridor, a phone screen, a basement, the corner of a kitchen after everyone has gone to bed. You do not need a fleet of spaceships when a buzzing strip light can make people hold their breath.

People sit in a dark cinema while a bright screen fills the room

For internet-native directors, that is a gift. Low budgets are less embarrassing there. Atmosphere can beat scale. A viewer arriving from YouTube or TikTok is already primed for compression: the clipped dread of a found clip, the half-seen shape at the end of a hallway, the comment section doing some of the world-building after the video stops.

Obsession belongs to that same weather system, though it should not be reduced to a matching data point. Barker came through comedy-horror online, and the leap to a theatrical hit suggests that young audiences are not allergic to cinemas. They are allergic to being patronised by films that feel several memos removed from the way they actually talk, fear and joke.

At that point, the box-office story becomes cultural rather than corporate. If Backrooms and Obsession have pulled younger viewers into the room, the lesson is not that studios should trawl YouTube for IP until the next gold seam appears. Please, no. The lesson is that taste has moved faster than the institutions built to package it. By the time a studio notices a mood, the audience may have been living inside it for years.

Naturally, Hollywood may hear the wrong thing. It may decide the future is a spreadsheet of internet myths, each one attached to a creator, a modest budget and a hope that teenagers will do the marketing for free. Dreary, that. It would turn the whole movement into another extraction machine, mining oddness until the oddness stops breathing.

What Hollywood is really buying

My hope is that the industry notices the less convenient part: these films work when they preserve the sensation of being made by someone with an itch, not a committee with a trend forecast. The camera has to feel as though it is following a thought the director has not quite domesticated yet.

A group watches a film from red cinema seats, faces lit by the screen

Precedent exists. Danny and Michael Philippou, who came through the RackaRacka YouTube channel before Talk to Me, already made the path look less like a fluke. Mark Fischbach, better known as Markiplier, has been part of the creator-to-feature-director conversation too. None of this means every creator should make a film, or that every film needs to behave like a piece of internet lore. Some should not. Most should not.

Their presence changes the imagination of who gets to stand behind the camera. That is not a small thing. For a long time, the director origin myth was built around access: to equipment, to mentors, to cities, to festivals, to the social codes that tell a gatekeeper you belong in the room. Online work does not erase those advantages. It does, however, create a second record. Did the thing move people? Did they come back? Did they argue about it? Did it teach them how to watch?

Maybe I am over-reading the romance of it. There is every chance the next year brings a half-dozen cynical attempts to manufacture Backrooms-adjacent dread in boardrooms where no one has ever fallen asleep with YouTube autoplay still running. The machine learns quickly when money appears. It learns the wrong lesson even faster.

For the moment, though, there is something pleasingly unruly about it all. A 20-year-old director turns an online nightmare into a number-one film. Another creator pulls a horror audience through word of mouth. Critics reach for labels. Studios reach for phones. Somewhere, in some bedroom with a half-decent microphone and too many tabs open, another teenager is probably learning where to hold a cut for one beat longer than comfort allows.

So maybe that is the actual shift. YouTube has not defeated Hollywood. Too neat, not really true. The old centre of gravity has slipped. The strange corridor is no longer outside the industry. It is leading people in.

Share
Jordan Atkinson
Written by
Jordan Atkinson

Melbourne film and television critic. Streams the lot so you don't have to. Writes about the Australian screen industry and what's worth a night in.

More to read